First Lady Jill Biden faced a wave of criticism following the release of the White House’s annual Christmas video. Posted on social media on Wednesday night, December 13, 2023, the video featured performers from Dorrance Dance in a lively rendition of Tchaikovsky’s “The Nutcracker Suite” within the festive setting of the White House. The theme “Magic, Wonder, and Joy,” aimed to evoke a childlike sense of awe. Mrs. Biden described the video as “a bit of magic, wonder, and joy,” showcasing dancers in flamboyant attire moving through the President’s residence, adorned with red and white themed Christmas trees and decorations. 

The White House had announced this theme on November 27, seeking to inspire visitors to reconnect with their youthful spirit and the joy of the holiday season. However, the response on social media was predominantly negative, with many users finding the production odd and in poor taste. One user dubbed it “The United States of Bananas.” Critics felt it strayed from traditional Christmas values, with some questioning the expense for taxpayers. The video drew unfavorable comparisons to former First Lady Melania Trump’s more traditional Christmas presentations.

Some viewers expressed discomfort and confusion over the video, with reactions ranging from feeling embarrassed to describing it as nightmarish. Concerns were raised about its suitability for children and its deviation from classic Christmas imagery. On the other hand, a few viewers commended Dorrance Dance’s creative efforts, appreciating the unique take on White House holiday celebrations. In contrast, Melania Trump’s 2018 Christmas video, featuring distinctive red trees, also faced criticism but was seen as more aligned with conventional Christmas themes.