The woman who won one of the largest civil awards ever entered against Bill Cosby wants the comedian jailed until he tells a court where his money is.
Donna Motsinger, 84, a former Northern California waitress, has asked a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge to hold Cosby in contempt for ignoring an order to open his books, according to court documents reported Nov. 12, 2026. Motsinger won a $59.25 million verdict in the spring and says she has received none of it — no money, no bank statements, no answers to the court’s questions.
Her lawyers wrote in the filing that Cosby’s “noncompliance is not partial, late, or excusable. It is total,” and asked the court to haul him in and make him explain the refusal. If he does not show up, they want an arrest warrant.
What the Judge Demanded in Writing
Judge Bradley S. Phillips ordered Cosby on Oct. 9 to give verified answers, without objection, to written questions about his assets, and to pay $1,560 in sanctions to Motsinger’s lawyers. The order gave him 10 days, setting a deadline of Oct. 19. Motsinger says nothing arrived, and that Cosby has disclosed nothing about bank accounts, income or other holdings since the verdict.
The filing seeks fines of up to $1,000 and five days in jail for each violation, plus $3,284 in attorney’s fees and costs. If the court finds Cosby in contempt and he still refuses, her lawyers want him held until the information is turned over.
Why Jail Isn’t About the Money
Joshua Wurtzel, an attorney at Schlam Stone & Dolan, called an arrest warrant a “real possibility” — though not over the unpaid judgment itself. Courts typically cannot jail people over unpaid civil debts, Wurtzel noted. Contempt, he said, is both a serious threat to Cosby and a lever to force compliance, because his exposure comes from the order he is accused of ignoring rather than from the debt.
A debtor’s exam, a separate tool available to Motsinger, would require a full accounting of Cosby’s assets and where they sit, including accounts, investments, real estate, business interests and income. Under California law, a judge can order a debtor to show cause, and if the debtor is personally served and fails to appear, the sheriff can be directed to bring him in. A contempt finding could keep him there until he answers.
Easier to Issue Than to Serve
Phillips has not ruled on the contempt request, and no arrest warrant has been issued. A hearing is scheduled for January 2027. Even then, a warrant is easier to issue than to serve, and considerably harder to serve if Cosby is outside California.
Her Lawyer Says He Was Sharp
Cosby has skipped three depositions scheduled for April, June and September in a separate federal case brought by 10 women in Nevada, according to reporting attributed to the accusers’ lawyers. An attorney for Cosby has cited legal blindness, limited mobility and age-related health problems.
His attorney has also said his health has worsened recently and that he requires an assistant at depositions. Jesse Creed, Motsinger’s attorney, offers a different account, describing Cosby as sharp and healthy at a deposition in November 2025. Creed accuses him of hiding assets, an allegation that no court has found to be true.
In the Nevada matter, another attorney asked a federal judge to compel Cosby’s deposition or enter a default judgment. Jennifer Bonjean, Cosby’s attorney, has said her client does not leave home and is in poor health.
Bonjean told jurors at trial that the punitive award was not a question of deterrence. After the verdict, she said Cosby had been denied a fair trial, and that claims reaching back half a century leave a defendant no real way to answer them. Phillips rejected Cosby’s bid for a new trial in May, finding no irregularity that made the trial unfair, and an appeal is pending.
The Night at the Trident
Motsinger was waiting tables at the Trident in Sausalito, Calif., in 1972, when Cosby was in the area to record a stand-up performance at a nearby theater. She testified that she was given wine and pills, after which she lost awareness. Her complaint says she went in and out of consciousness, and she says she woke up with her clothes stripped.
The case reached a jury because California reopened a window for sexual assault claims that had expired under old time limits. On March 23, jurors found Cosby liable for drugging and sexually assaulting her. They awarded $19.25 million in compensatory damages — $17.5 million for past mental trauma and $1.75 million for future mental suffering — then added $40 million in punitive damages.
“This verdict is not just about me—it’s about finally being heard and holding Mr. Cosby accountable,” Motsinger said via her lawyers at the time.
Cosby, 89, has denied every allegation of nonconsensual sexual contact and maintains his innocence. More than 60 women have accused him of misconduct.
Motsinger was among the anonymous Jane Does who testified in Andrea Constand’s 2005 civil case against Cosby. Constand’s allegations later produced his only criminal conviction, in Pennsylvania in 2018, and he served more than two years of a three-to-10-year sentence before the state Supreme Court threw out the conviction in 2021 over a violated prosecutorial agreement. Another accuser won damages in a 2022 civil case.










